“It was the accordian of the brilliant geraint watkins that helped make this a big hit providing a great cajun feel to it.” Facebook · Shakin' Stevens · 8 months ago $1 Record Reviews: Shakin' Stevens' eponymous album

“This song is a masterpiece. Shakin' Stevens' brilliant rendition of the song and his amazing voice made the song unbeatable...” Facebook · Shakin' Stevens · 3 months ago

While some reviewers find the lyrics to be "standard rock n’ roll love song fare," many appreciate the song's energy and originality within the context of the early 1980s music scene.

“It's mainly that accordion really, the cajun feel sets it apart from his other songs a bit.” Rate Your Music Fan Sentiment

"Oh Julie" by Shakin’ Stevens is widely regarded as a standout track in his career, particularly because it was written by the artist himself rather than being a cover of a 1950s standard. Critics and fans alike highlight its unique , largely credited to the "brilliant" accordion playing of Geraint Watkins. Critical Perspectives