The contestants had to choose and replicate one of several "incredible" desserts displayed in the kitchen. The baker who came closest to a perfect replication earned an immunity pin, while those with the worst performances faced elimination.

Dara Yu was noted for her confidence and success with a complicated four-layer cake.

Shelly Flash faced significant stress with her Napoleon dough texture. Tommy Walton also struggled with time constraints, nearly failing to get his tart base in the oven with only 40 minutes remaining.